When it comes to choosing the best case for your iPhone 16 Pro or Pro Max, both the Shield Case and the Maizcase offer a compelling mix of luxury, protection, and sustainability. However, each case has its distinct advantages, and your choice will depend on what matters most to you—whether it’s maximum protection, a luxurious leather feel, or eco-friendly innovation. Let’s break down both cases side by side to help you decide.

Protection: Which Case Keeps Your iPhone Safer?

In terms of raw protection, the Shield Case stands out. With ImpactCore technology and Military Grade MIL-STD-810 certification, it’s designed to withstand drops from up to 5 metres (15 feet). If you're looking for the most robust defense for your device, the Shield Case is the superior option. It’s slim, but tough as nails—ideal for those who value extra protection without adding too much bulk.

The Maizcase, while protective, doesn’t boast military-grade certification. It does, however, offer a 1mm raised bezel and a machined-metal camera bump that keep your phone’s screen and camera safe from scratches and minor impacts. If you’re careful with your phone and prefer a lighter, less rugged option, the Maizcase still provides ample protection for daily use, but it might not hold up as well in extreme drops or rough environments.

Winner for Protection: Shield Case

Material & Design: Leather vs. Bio-Leather

The Shield Case uses Velore full-grain calfskin leather sourced from the Netherlands, offering a luxurious feel and a patina that improves with time. If you’re drawn to the aesthetic of premium leather, which ages like a fine leather jacket, this case is the one for you. The Japanese microfibre lining and super-clicky buttons add to the premium experience, making every interaction with your phone feel satisfying.

The Maizcase, on the other hand, takes a more eco-conscious approach with Italian bio-leather made from corn and recycled materials. This bio-leather feels like traditional leather but offers a more sustainable alternative. If you’re someone who prioritizes environmental responsibility without sacrificing quality, the Maizcase is an excellent choice. It has the same timeless look and feel as leather, but with a smaller carbon footprint and minimal water usage in production.

In terms of aesthetics, both cases are equally stylish, but your preference may lean toward either the premium, natural feel of the Shield Case or the eco-conscious, futuristic vibe of the Maizcase.

Winner for Material & Design: Depends on preference – Shield Case for luxury, Maizcase for sustainability

Sustainability: The Green Option

Sustainability is where the Maizcase really shines. Made from bio-leather, a blend of corn and cereals with recycled polyester, the Maizcase is designed to minimize its environmental impact. Additionally, 98% of the water used in production is recovered, highlighting the brand’s commitment to eco-friendly manufacturing processes.

The Shield Case, while still eco-friendly, doesn’t quite reach the same level of sustainability. Its leather is tanned using DriTan, a water-free tanning process, and the case incorporates recycled materials, earning it a Leather Working Group Gold certification. While both cases show a commitment to the environment, the Maizcase goes a step further by eliminating the need for animal-based leather entirely.

Winner for Sustainability: Maizcase

Weight & Slimness: Which Case Feels Better in Your Pocket?

The Maizcase is notably lighter at 60 grams, making it the better option for those who prefer a minimalist feel. With dimensions of 15.2cm x 7.2cm x 0.8cm, it’s slim and compact, ideal for users who don’t want to feel the added weight in their pocket or bag.

The Shield Case weighs in at 70 grams, slightly heavier due to its military-grade protection and full-grain leather. While it’s still relatively slim (16.0cm x 8.0cm x 1.0cm), it has a more substantial feel, which might appeal to those who prefer a case that adds noticeable heft and durability to their phone.

Winner for Weight & Slimness: Maizcase

MagSafe Compatibility & Everyday Use

Both cases support MagSafe technology, allowing for wireless charging and seamless accessory integration. Whether you’re using a MagSafe charger or a wallet attachment, both cases perform equally well in this regard. They also feature super-clicky, ultra-responsive buttons, ensuring that you don’t lose any functionality when pressing your phone’s side buttons.

Where the Shield Case may have a slight edge is in everyday handling. The full-grain leather’s texture offers a grippier, more substantial feel in the hand, while the bio-leather of the Maizcase, though smooth, might be slightly slicker depending on your grip preferences.

Winner for MagSafe & Everyday Use: Draw – Both cases perform excellently here.

Price & Value

Both cases are priced at £59, making them premium options. However, the Shield Case offers more in terms of sheer protection and luxury materials, which may justify the price if you’re looking for high-end durability and aesthetics. On the other hand, the Maizcase gives you the opportunity to invest in a product that aligns with your sustainability values, without sacrificing style or function.

Winner for Price & Value: Depends on your priorities – Shield Case for protection and luxury, Maizcase for sustainability.

Final Verdict

For Maximum Protection: If rugged protection is your primary concern, the iPhone 16 Pro Max Shield Case is the clear winner, with military-grade durability, full-grain leather, and a tough, no-compromise design. It’s perfect for those who want to invest in a long-lasting, stylish, and robust case.

For Sustainability and Minimalism: The Maizcase for iPhone 16 Pro is the best choice if you’re seeking a lighter, eco-friendly option that doesn’t skimp on style or protection. Its bio-leather construction and sustainable manufacturing processes make it a standout for environmentally conscious users.

Ultimately, both cases are exceptional, offering a mix of high-end protection and thoughtful design. Your decision will come down to whether you value rugged luxury or a planet-friendly minimalist approach. Either way, you’re making a solid investment in protecting your iPhone with style and conscience. You can buy the Mujjo iPhone 16 cases from Mujjo's website.